In 1995, the Horror Maestro and the Comedy Legend Teamed Up for an Underrated Horror Masterpiece

The director's recent project may have breathed new life into the idea of African American undead, but the origins of this cinematic category date back to the Blaxploitation era. One of the most iconic early examples was the seminal 1972 movie Blacula. In that motion picture, William Marshall's character is bitten by Dracula and cursed with the demeaning name “Blacula.” Initially conceived as a caricature, Marshall transformed the role into something majestic, giving his character an historical origin as Mamuwalde, a noble royal from Africa.

Decades later, the comedic star seemed to take a cue from Marshall, enriching his own protagonist's lore in the director's take on the Black vampire subgenre: Vampire in Brooklyn. The protagonist Maximillian is a heir of Dracula whose ancestors escaped to Egypt, and later to the Bermuda Triangle, after being persecuted to the edge of annihilation. Vampire in Brooklyn demonstrates that Black vampire stories can be humorous, frightening, and thought-provoking all at once, securing its place in the canon by juggling all three while honoring the subgenre's legacy.

Debuted 30 years ago on Oct. 27, 1995, Vampire in Brooklyn is now available on a popular platform, making it an must-see if you need a dash of humor with your frights this Halloween.

A Tale of Two Cities

Similar to the royal character in Coming to America (the actor's 1988 masterpiece), Maximillian is drawn to the Big Apple. But instead of journeying from Zamunda to Queens, he arrives from the mysterious region into Brooklyn, aiming to locate and ensure the continuation of his vampire lineage with an offspring of his clan.

The character makes his entrance in New York on a phantom vessel whose sailors has been mysteriously slaughtered, a nod to Nosferatu. The ship is discovered by ship inspector Silas Green (John Witherspoon) and his relative Julius Jones (Kadeem Hardison), two of the most humorous personalities in the movie. Silas then witnesses a black wolf leap from the ship, dart into an alley, and transform into a man — like the iconic routine from the longer Black or White video. Groovy 1970s-inspired soundtrack starts, establishing the mood for a film that expertly mixes scares and laughs.

Artistic Goals

Recently after his final entry in the Nightmare on Elm Street series, the director was keen to break from his horror reputation and create a more blended comedy (his next film after Vampire in Brooklyn was Scream, which exploited horror tropes for both laughs and genuine scares). Meanwhile, Murphy aimed to defy assumptions by diving into a pure scary movie rooted in vampire mythology. The conflict of those creative goals explains the film's exposition-heavy opening of the protagonist's backstory and its somewhat slow commencement. But when the film hits its stride, it opens up to its strengths — like its diverse ensemble.

The acclaimed actress, as the vampire's love interest, plays police officer Rita Veder, whose dynamic with her colleague and romantic lead, detective Justice (Allen Payne), adds a crime-drama edge to the story. One of African American film's most praised actresses, she gives a powerful performance with Payne, a familiar face from the time. In the meantime, Murphy spends most of his screen time with Kadeem Hardison, creating a uproarious Abbott-and-Costello-style duo as the actor's Julius Jones becomes Max’s undead lackey. (Seeing Julius sink deeper and deeper into his macabre part as his skin decays during the movie is a standout moment of how the star's comedic style enhances the comedy and horror, even when employed by the cast).

Dark Seduction

When the two leads meet and the stars appear together, the film hits its stride — the tension heightens, the scares intensify, and their sinister attraction takes center stage. The vampire's scheme is to remove all Rita has in her life and then intervene. He murders her roommate, creates conflict between her and her love interest, and even uses Nutty Professor-esque make-up effects to masquerade as a preacher and undermine her faith.

As the story progresses, it becomes increasingly Gothic, featuring transformations and revelations of origins. This leads to a final section packed with temptation, as mortality and damnation hang in the balance. The movie concludes with a teaser suggesting a potential sequel, one that could have happened had the movie performed better. Vampire in Brooklyn made a modest box office return and got mostly negative reviews upon release. Over time, it found new life as a cult favorite, with reviewers later applauding Craven’s direction, the spark between Murphy and Bassett, and its clever mix of horror and comedy. The movie shows glimpses of genius that might have shone brighter had all participants been aligned on a unified vision, rather than producing the mixed-genre result audiences received. Still, Vampire in Brooklyn has rightfully earned its place in the canon of Black horror, an underappreciated but impactful film characterized by its bold style and memorable acting.

Glen Aguilar
Glen Aguilar

Eleanor is a personal finance enthusiast and seasoned blogger who loves uncovering the best deals to help Brits save money effortlessly.